The Progressive Post

Turning Surplus into a Social Benefit


Consumer goods waste is worth billions of euros every year. However, current tax legislation in many countries makes donation more expensive than disposal.

Every day, consumers can choose from a wide range of products when shopping for their personal daily needs, kitting out their households with appliances and buying other long-lasting consumer goods. Food waste has been at the centre of public attention for a while now, but little is known about the flipside of the choice we enjoy: that consumer goods worth billions of euros are thrown away every year in Europe.

There are many reasons why consumer goods are not sold as planned: slight imperfections such as off-colouring, mislabelling, or damaged cartons and pallets, but also the end of seasonal and promotional lines, product relaunches, the closing down of factories or outlets and plain, old, ordinary surpluses.

In Germany alone, it is estimated that consumer goods worth over 7 billion euros are disposed of every year – ending up in landfills or incineration plants. About one third of these products – worth 2 billion euros – is perfectly safe for consumer use and needed by charities for their daily work.

Avoiding waste by distributing donations to charities

Taking surplus products as donations from companies and distributing them to charities is an innovative way to avoid waste and turn affluence into social benefit. This work is carried out by product-redistributing charities in several European countries. In Germany, Innatura is the only platform building the bridge between companies who want to give, but do not know to whom, and charities. This “charity-to-charity” model offers companies an alternative to disposing, while at the same time improving their environmental footprint and creating social benefits. A wide range of products such as toys, tools, appliances, personal hygiene products and educational material are distributed to over 2,000 charities. Receiving charities, in turn, work with a broad range of beneficiaries such as children, families, homeless people and refugees. They are vetted rigorously and contribute a small handling fee – typically between five and 20 percent of the products´ market price – to the platform´s operating cost.

An international network fostering product philanthropy

In Kind Direct in the UK, one of the Prince´s Charities founded in 1997, has launched the In Kind Direct International network. Together with Innatura in Germany and Dons Solidaires in France, these three charities are promoting the idea of product philanthropy and have collectively convinced over 1,300 donor companies to entrust them with the distribution of donated products worth over 300 million euros to over 8,000 charities. Together, more than 25,000 tonnes of goods have been diverted from landfill. Members collaborate to share donations, best practices, general policies and processes to enable goods to be distributed in the most effective way, thus maximizing benefit for people in need and the charities which serve them.

A call to action  

Donating products for social causes has a direct impact on avoiding waste – in many cases, product waste causes more harm through disposal than food waste. The donated products contribute directly to donor companies measuring their waste and working on improving their resource management. At the same time, the work of charities can be supported by allowing them a larger mileage with their budget, mostly to expand their core activities.

In order to increase both the environmental and social impact, several incentives are necessary:

  • Consumer goods companies need to become aware of the possibility of safely donating their surplus goods to charities, with one reliable partner for distribution and the assurance that their brands will be protected.
  • Charities need to realise that they can achieve much more with their budgets when they procure in-kind donations – what they need, when they need it, and in the necessary quantities – for a small handling fee, rather than buying on the market.
  • Taxation of in-kind donations creates unnecessary waste by making donating more expensive than disposal. In some countries, for example Germany, a donation has to be valued and accounted for as sales revenues. The VAT the donor has to pay is only partially offset by donation receipts. Food donations can be written off in most countries now, but donating non-food products can imply costs many times greater than disposal. Governments have to find a way to make donating products less expensive than disposing of them. As VAT is a European issue, the European Parliament can play a crucial role in promoting product philanthropy across its member states and thus avoid unnecessary waste.
  • “Charity-to-charity” models are excluded from almost all funding – because they do not work directly with the needy. These models, however, dramatically increase the effectiveness and efficiency of the charity sector and improve the leverage of tax money and donations. Public and private funders should therefore make charity-to-charity models eligible for funding.


Photo © lornet / Shutterstock, Inc.
Find all related publications

The transformation of the mainstream right and its impact on (social) democracy


Expected labour market effects of the Green Deal Industrial Plan

The potential of labour policy for Just Transition regions

Labour migration in the Western Balkans

Balkan Focus series

A European feminist foreign policy?

The need for a progressive and transformative approach
Find all related news

FEPS welcomes the signing of the La Hulpe Declaration


FEPS supports the declaration of Portimão calling for affordable housing in the EU

Affordable housing needs Europe, Europe needs affordable housing

FEPS stands with Zita Gurmai against persecution from Orban regime


Interview with Maria João Rodrigues on the need for EU treaty changes with Euronews

Find all related in the media
In the media

Karl Polanyi against the ‘free market’ dystopia

by Social Europe 23/04/2024
In this article published in Social Europe, FEPS Secretary General László Andor reassess the Hungarian social scientist’s legacy.

Jetzt oder nie: Österreichs digitales Schicksal entscheidet sich (auch) im Klassenzimmer!

by Börse Express 14/04/2024
'Now or never: Austria's digital fate will (also) be decided in the classroom!' Börse Express's article mentions FEPS policy brief 'Europe needs high-tech talent'

EU-VÍZIÓ, Dull Szabolcs újságíró Andor Lászlóval beszélget

by MÚOSZ Magyar Újságírók Országos Szövetsége 11/04/2024
On the occasion of the 20th anniversary of the EU great Eastern enlargement, FEPS Secretary General László Andor talks, in this video interview to the Hungarian Journalists' Association, the functioning of the Commission and its further development.

Sustainable democracies need a sustainable media sector, says Jourová

by EURACTIV 02/04/2024
FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues discusses AI and journalism at Stars4Media event