The State of the Union – the two sides of a speech

The qualitative leap which was introduced in the European project in the wake of the […]

FEPS President
16/09/2021

The qualitative leap which was introduced in the European project in the wake of the Covid-19 crisis has brought higher levels of solidarity and cohesion. But there is still a long way to go. The speech of the president of the European Commission has outlined a few further steps, but many more need to be done. Moreover, it was shy about a key issue: for the new phase of its project, Europe needs to make a democratic transformation of the way its democracy works at various levels.

This time, Ursula von der Leyen could present her annual State of the Union address, building on the feeling of some relief that many feel to see the pandemic more under control. Last year, we still did not know whether there would be a vaccine and an effective European co-operation and whether the European recovery plan could take off. The Portuguese Presidency has made it possible to clarify these issues in the right direction.

A European health prevention authority has been announced, but a European Health Union that guarantees universal access to quality health care is something much wider. The commitment to strengthen European’s support for global vaccination against Covid-19 is also a positive announcement, but a broader commitment to a multilateral framework is missing.

The preparation of a European strategy to develop personal care also makes a lot of sense, not only to respond to the pandemic but also to create a new pillar of a welfare state for the 21st century, able to address demographic ageing and the question of reconciliation of family and professional life – without which there can be no real equality between women and men. But there are other pillars of this welfare state that are yet to be reinvented to respond to the new social inequalities and new forms of poverty.

Yes, the climate transition must be supported by a specific Social Fund that compensates for job losses. But recovery plans as a whole have to be designed to create new jobs in new activities, especially to avoid sacrificing a new young generation. It is essential that this job creation can take place in all regions and not just in the most dynamic parts of Europe. The Alma programme to enable young people to access jobs in other countries, as Erasmus has done for education, is to be welcomed, but mobility in Europe must be voluntary and not a mere answer to the lack of education and employment opportunities in certain regions.

Yes, the digital transition is well pointed out as decisive, but a strategy has yet to be defined for a European pathway that is different from the American and the Chinese ones. The starting point should be the use of European big data in the field of health and education and incentives to innovative industries to develop algorithms, services and products that are in line with a European, sustainable,and inclusive way of life. But the formulation of a genuine innovation policy for the digital society remains stalled by the canons of a past paradigm, that of competition in the European internal market. Meanwhile, major public procurement operations that are currently underway in education, telework and health could benefit more non-European companies.

The so-called recovery and resilience plans should be understood as plans to rebuild European economies on new bases. This is a long and huge undertaking that requires a long-term financial boost, counting on a European budgetary capacity and public debt issuance and on national budgets with updated common rules. The famous three per cent deficit and 60 per cent debt rules that were defined in the 1990s have little to do with the present and future reality.

In the face of the clumsy American withdrawal from Afghanistan, the President’s speech acknowledges the evidence. Today’s world is multipolar, systemic competition is growing, and Europe must strengthen its strategic autonomy with its own initiatives: humanitarian interventions, defence capacity, enlargement to the Western Balkans and the launch of an alternative initiative to the new Chinese Silk Road – the Belt and Road Initiative – and as US president Joe Biden did at the last G7 summit: the European Global Gateway. However, she has failed to enhance the EU’s commitment to the multilateral framework, whilst UN Secretary General António Guterres has just presented an ambitious plan for his second term, called ‘Our Common Agenda’.

However, the President was shy about the main issue. For the new phase of its project, Europe needs to make a democratic transformation of the way its democracy works at various levels. Firstly, in the light of current authoritarian drifts, to ensure that the fundamentals of the rule of law are respected throughout its territory. But also to unlock European decisions that have dragged on for years: minimum wage, minimum corporate tax, humanitarian external action, defence and the right of asylum are some of the striking examples. On these topics, does anyone doubt which way the majority opinion of Europeans would decide?

I end with a personal tribute to a very good and dear friend, European hero who has just left us and who has done marvelous things to promote democracy at all levels, local, national, European, and international: Jorge Sampaio, the former President of the Republic of Portugal. I believe he was an inspiration for all of us.

Find all related publications
Publications
21/09/2023

A European Health Union

A blueprint for generations
24/08/2023

Montenegro’s political transition. From Djukanović to where?

Balkan Focus policy brief series
24/08/2023

Embracing the Western Balkan countries’ EU accession process. A vital question mark of the EU

Balkan Focus policy brief series
31/05/2023

Is the digital transition a lever for structural reforms or does it reinforce the divide?

Recovery Watch series
Find all related events
Events
Upcoming
26/10/2023
Brussels, Belgium (Hybrid)

The rise of political entrepreneurs in Europe

Next Left lecture IV
Past
18 - 20/09/2023
FEPS HQ

FEPS Annual Autumn Academy 2023

Beyond 2024
22 - 24/06/2023
Thessaloniki, Greece (Expert meeting)

Friends of the Western Balkans Thessaloniki meeting

20 years anniversary of the Thessaloniki Declaration
Find all related news
News
29/06/2023

Friends of the Western Balkans’ statement

Thessaloniki, 24 June 2023 We, the network of the Friends of the Western Balkans, representatives […]
30/05/2023

FEPS renews its support to ULB students’ magazine Eyes on Europe

FEPS is proud to renew its collaboration with the ULB student non-profit association “Eyes on Europe“ at […]
30/03/2023

Joint priorities for the Defence of Democracy Package

We are proud to share that FEPS has contributed to a paper summarising the Joint […]
01/12/2022

Progressive MPs and MEPs advocate for the fulfilment of the promise made in Thessaloniki to the Western Balkans

Open letter to the European leaders ahead of the EU - Western Balkans Summit
Find all related in the media
In the media

Borko Stefanović: Odmah usaglasiti spoljnu politiku sa EU i napraviti od Srbije dobro i sigurno mesto za život

by Danas 26/06/2023
Borko Stefanović, deputy president of the Freedom and Justice Party, participated in the international meeting in Thessaloniki organized by FEPS, the Friends of the Western Balkans and FES

Ocidente em minoria ou reforma da governação global?

by Público 08/06/2023
'West in minority or global governance reform?' In Público's article, FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues explains the importance of reforming the actual global governance system

Research shows Ireland is too reliant on voluntary sector for mental health services

by RTÉ Radio 1 27/03/2023
RTÉ Radio 1 talks about our case studies 'Is an EU-wide approach to the mental health crisis necessary?', published in collaboration with Think-tank for Action on Social Change (TASC)

Irish mental health services ‘too hospital-centric’

by Irish Examiner 23/03/2023
Irish Examiner article on FEPS and TASC policy study "Is an EU-wide approach to the Mental Health Crisis necessary?"