In the Shadow of Basel. How Competitive Politics Bred the Crisis

This article by Matthias Thiemann critically investigates the reasons for the lack of regulation on […]

Policy Study

09/10/2014

This article by Matthias Thiemann critically investigates the reasons for the lack of regulation on the shadow banking sector and its linkages to the banking system. The author poses a fundamental question: Why did banking regulators around the globe permit their banks to evade core capital requirements by acting in the bank-based shadow system before the crisis of 2007?

Off-balance sheet securitisation activities by banks have been a central transmission mechanism during the current financial crisis. Banks had “parked” securitised assets, worth hundreds of billions of dollars in the shadow banking system, essentially engaging in proprietary trading-off balance sheet, exempt from banking regulation. When suspicion over the quality of these securitised assets reached the money markets, these refused to continue refinancing the proprietary trading of banks and the assets parked in the shadow banking sector reappeared on the balance sheets of banks, creating losses due to substantial write-offs.

The paper by Matthias Thiemann argues that regulatory inaction by banking regulators was caused by the mismatch between the level at which the problem occurred (globally) and the level at which banking regulators could address it (nationally).  In particular, the paper argues that concerns over competitive inequities and the possibility for the exclusion of certain activities from international banking regulation through national laws were the structural conditions for the regulatory race to the bottom for off-balance sheet securitisation activities of banks. These pressures emanating from the national regulation of global markets explain why regulatory action to close these loopholes has been mostly absent before the crisis.

 

Author Matthias Thiemann: Post-Doctoral Student, Centre For Capitalism, Globalization And Governance, Essec Business School, Cergy Pontoise, France

See other recent articles by Matthias Thiemann: Regulating the off-balance sheet exposure of banks: A comparison pre- and post-crisis

Find all related publications
Publications
17/06/2025

Lessons learned from the Recovery and Resilience Facility for a future European fiscal capacity

The creation of the Recovery and Resilience Fund (RRF) as a response to the pandemic […]
05/05/2025

Shaping a European budget fit for climate action and a just transition

The negotiations for the next EU Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) – the long-term budget at […]
22/04/2025

Trade, trust, and transition: Shaping the next transatlantic chapter

Essays series by FEPS and Center for American Progress (CAP)
08/04/2025

The profit-price spiral in food and energy

Analysis and toolbox to fight inflation
Find all related Progressive Post
Progressive Post
11/04/2025

Trump’s tariff boomerang

Most trade pundits (and a few others) were shocked by the magnitude of Trump’s tariff […]
11/04/2025

Trade as a force for good jobs

Tariffs and trade wars are never good for workers who inevitably end up paying the […]
Find all related events
Events
Upcoming
03/09/2025
Brussels, Belgium

Inflation preparedness in the EU

Lessons learned and a new Inflation Governance Framework
Past
17/06/2025
Bratislava, Slovakia

The role of profits in the European inflation shock

The case of Slovakia
19 - 21/06/2025
Siena, Italy

Siena Vision Conference on the Europe of the Future – 2025

Time to be bold
Find all related news
News
26/02/2025

FEPS reaction to the European Commission’s Clean Industrial Deal

What Teresa Ribera presented today is an ambitious plan that makes the case for Europe […]
07/02/2025

FEPS President on the European car industry and the Competitive Compass on Euronews ‘Brussels, my love?’

FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues took part in the Euronews talk show ‘Brussels, my love?‘ […]
27/06/2024

Join Tax the EU Billionaires Day!

Do you know that the richest 1% in Europe owns half of European wealth? Join […]
18/01/2024

FEPS President at Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?’

Alongside German conservative MEP Lars Patrick Berg and Fabian Zuleeg, Chief economist and director of […]
Find all related in the media
In the media

Tévedés azt hinni, hogy Trump után visszatérhetünk a régi kerékvágásba

by telex 24/04/2025
“It’s a mistake to think we can go back to the old normal after Trump”. Interview with FEPS Secretary General László Andor in Telex (HU), where he discusses the global trade tensions triggered by Trump-era tariffs, the shifting US-China dynamic, and the need for the EU to develop a new strategic approach in a permanently changed world order.

Brussels, my love? Europe’s economy in a struggle for survival

by Euronews 21/10/2024
FEPS director of studies and policy David Rinaldi participated in this episode of Euronews’ show ‘Brussels my love’.

Megadóztatná a szupergazdagokat? Ha igen, most tehet valamit

by Zöld Hang 04/10/2024
'Would you tax the super-rich? If so, you can do something now' Interview to FEPS Secretary General, László Andor on the 'Tax the rich' EU initiative by the Hungarian newspaper Zöld Hang.

Orbánov boj z zunanjim sovražnikom ni bil kos inflaciji

by DELO 28/05/2024
In an article in Delo, László Andor criticises Viktor Orbán government's economic policies, such as not allowing Hungary to join the euro area, which he believes would have helped curb inflation. He also criticises the government for blaming external enemies such as the President of the European Commission, to cover up its own failures.