Media in Europe: Subsidiarity should be reconsidered

Policy Study

09/10/2014

The Hungarian media law symbolises the need for the European Union to assume its responsibilities to defend media freedom. Interpretations of this law diverge, however. In Hungary, it is seen as the straw that broke the camel’s back, coming on top of a series of laws aiming to strengthen the current government’s powers. In Europe, following the Italian, Romanian and Bulgarian cases, it has become a symbol of debate on a European media law.

The question of whether an EU directive is necessary and would be more effective is a valid one. What added value would a directive contribute? And, most importantly, considering cultural, linguistic and legal differences is it conceivable?

As the recent cases show, the Commission’s approach of legislating in the field of the media in order to complete the single market does not constitute an absolute guarantee. There is no direct correlation between a larger number of players on the market, greater competition and greater media independence. Despite this approach, and despite the fact that the laws comply with EU legislation, the Hungarian law still includes ambiguous articles with respect to the appointment of officials and media control. Concentration problems are not always solved satisfactorily in Italy and a homogenising effect can be seen in the programmes of private and public channels. The purpose of an EU regulation would not be to impose detailed rules like those at national level. However, as the cases mentioned above suggest, national legislation no longer suffices.

It fails to offer adequate guarantees in an increasingly interconnected world. Consequently, a European media framework law determining the bases and guiding principles for the functioning of this sector seems essential to effective protection of media freedom.

Article 5 of the Treaty on the European Union, the ‘subsidiarity principle’, is often evoked as a ground to object to a media law. Existing legislation is nevertheless inconsistent, does not cover all aspects and shows a number of major weaknesses.

Media freedom is an essential foundation of our democracies, however, since it enables us to take informed decisions during local, national and European elections. So there is a European dimension that calls into question the principle of subsidiarity. Furthermore, based on Articles 2 and 6 of the Treaty on European Union, a policy in support of media freedom could be seen as a sort of implicit competence.

In spite of the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty, which includes the European Union’s Charter of Fundamental Rights, the Commission still does not have the capacity to act in cases of violations of human rights in general. However, it seems that the current Commission does not intend in any case to evoke more fundamental human rights principles in this connection, but on the contrary to keep to the technical aspects, as seen in the criticisms Neelie Kroes sent to the Hungarian government. More positively, the joint resolution tabled in the European Parliament by members of the S&D, ALDE and Greens-EFA groups constitutes a more courageous approach.

Will the situation change once the European Union becomes a party to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)? It is still hard to say whether this change will have additional effects that could convince the Commission to adopt a more explicit approach to these problems and similar questions.

The Foundation for European Progressive Studies (FEPS) and its legal experts will work to advance a progressive European approach to the media, based on respect for democratic values and fundamental rights, and will propose progressive alternatives aimed at more coherent and effective European media legislation.

Find all related publications
Publications
16/05/2024

EU regulation on transparency and targeting of political advertising

FEPS YAN Series
14/05/2024

Inequality and populism

FEPS YAN Series
18/04/2024

The transformation of the mainstream right and its impact on (social) democracy

08/04/2024

EU regulation on transparency and targeting of political advertising?

FEPS Yan Series
Find all related Progressive Post
Progressive Post
25/04/2024

25 April, a very special democratic revolution

A personal memoir
24/04/2024

Croatia’s super election year starts with a possible sharp turn to the right

04/04/2024

The Democratic Shield: safeguarding democracy in the age of AI

Find all related events
Events
Past
03 - 04/05/2024
La Hulpe, Belgium

Training of Trainers first session

19/01/2024
Vienna, Austria and Brussels, Belgium

European Political Academy

22/04/2024
Vienna, Austria

The transformation of the European mainstream right and its impact on (social) democracy 

Find all related news
News
18/03/2024

FEPS President on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?’

NATO extension, Portuguese elections, far-right and gender equality were the topics of the debate
04/03/2024

FEPS at the PES Election Congress in Rome

24/01/2024

Spanish Minister Teresa Ribera awarded FEPS ‘Progressive Person of the Year’

30/03/2023

Joint priorities for the Defence of Democracy Package

Find all related in the media
In the media

Edição especial sobre as eleições europeias já nas bancas

by SÁBADO 21/05/2024
"Special Edition on the European Elections Now Available on Newsstands" Read the special edition by SÁBADO focusing on the European election in Portugal, with an interview by Maria João Rodrigues, FEPS President

Youth unemployment hurts communities, its time for a new deal, says Andor

by Euractiv 15/05/2024
Read FEPS Secretary General László Andor's interview on the consequences of youth unemployment for communities

AI won’t replace quality journalism, but sector needs safeguarding, says socialist think tank head

by Euractiv 18/03/2024
Interview with FEPS President on the role of media in Europe’s future

FEPS President on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?’

by Euronews 16/03/2024
FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues discusses NATO expansions and elections in Russia and Portugal on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?‘