Sharing the responsibility or shifting the focus?

The Responses of the EU and the Visegrád Countries to the Post-2015 Arrival of Migrants and Refugees

Policy Study

08/06/2017

The key research question of this paper is why the Visegrád group countries (the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia) are reluctant to participate in the EU schemes on solidarity with third states and within the EU.

The notions of solidarity, burden- and responsibility- sharing are clarified (together with related concepts, such as loyal cooperation) before reviewing in a systemic way the possible range of responsibility-sharing in regard to asylum seekers and persons in need of international protection. Scholarly and institutional proposals for burden-/ responsibility-sharing are presented as an arsenal of options available to the Visegrád Group and the EU in general.

An analysis of the Visegrád countries documents and actual situation with regard to the irregular movement proves that whereas they uniformly reject the idea of compulsory relocation within the EU of persons applying for international protection, in general the group is far from homogenous. Hungary and Poland significantly differ from the Czech Republic and Slovakia. Even within the group, Hungary may have acquired a specific position with its total denial of the fact that irregularly arriving persons may need protection within the EU.

The conclusion is that more responsibility-sharing within the EU as a whole would be needed, leading to a unified protection space, but in reality a shift of the focus emerges, with the effort to move protection into geographic areas outside the EU.

Read the policy study

Photo:  Zoltan Major

Network
Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI)
Find all related publications
Publications
23/06/2025

Europe’s strategic role in global development

A call for ambition and reform
22/04/2025

Trade, trust, and transition: Shaping the next transatlantic chapter

Essays series by FEPS and Center for American Progress (CAP)
24/03/2025

Europe and the war in Ukraine

From Russian aggression to a new Eastern policy
06/03/2025

European defence for security and peace

Ensuring the security and well-being of its citizens is at the core of the European […]
Find all related Progressive Post
Progressive Post
15/07/2025

EU-China summit: a new start is needed

In 2025, the European Union and the People’s Republic of China mark the 50th anniversary […]
10/07/2025

Schengen anniversary: a Dorian Gray effect?

The 40th anniversary of the Schengen area this year places the EU in an uncomfortable […]
26/06/2025

BRICS 2025: Brazil’s balancing act

Brazil will host the BRICS+ summit in July this year, marking 16 years since the […]
Find all related events
Events
Upcoming
28 - 29/11/2025
Copenhagen, Denmark

Call to Europe Denmark 2025

Call to Europe, held bi-annually in the country hosting the presidency of the Council of […]
Past
30/06/2025
Sevilla, Spain

New strategic partnerships for development: Developing countries and the EU

UN official side event
27 - 28/05/2025
Nairobi, Kenya (Expert meeting)

Progressive Migration Group – Nairobi

Migration is a defining issue at the heart of the Africa-EU partnership. As global power […]
Find all related news
News
13/03/2025

Europe’s defence strategy must be peace-oriented

FEPS Position Paper on European defence
03/12/2024

FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues at the 2024 Understanding China Conference

FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues participated in the 2024 Understanding China Conference, “Carry through the […]
15/11/2024

Ahead of G20, FEPS president at the T20 and C20 Summit 2024

FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues actively participated in the T20 and C20 Summits 2024, held […]
07/11/2024

US election results

Reaction by FEPS Secretary General
Find all related in the media
In the media

Tévedés azt hinni, hogy Trump után visszatérhetünk a régi kerékvágásba

by telex 24/04/2025
“It’s a mistake to think we can go back to the old normal after Trump”. Interview with FEPS Secretary General László Andor in Telex (HU), where he discusses the global trade tensions triggered by Trump-era tariffs, the shifting US-China dynamic, and the need for the EU to develop a new strategic approach in a permanently changed world order.

СТРАТЕГИЯТА ЗА ОТБРАНА НА ЕВРОПА ТРЯБВА ДА БЪДЕ ОРИЕНТИРАНА КЪМ МИРА

by Novi Vremena 27/03/2025
In the article "Europe’s defence strategy must be peace-oriented", the Bulgarian media Novi Vremena highlights FEPS position on European defence strategy presented by László Andor, David Rinaldi and Beatriz Abellán.

Italy’s scheme to offshore asylum claims should not be a model for the rest of Europe

by The Guardian 16/10/2024
Article from The Guardian which references the policy study "Responsibility-sharing or shifting? Implications of the New Pact for future EU cooperation with third countries" by FEPS, FES and EPC.

FEPS President on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?’

by Euronews 16/03/2024
FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues discusses NATO expansions and elections in Russia and Portugal on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?‘