From debunking to prebunking: How to get ahead of disinformation on migration in the EU

Despite increasing efforts to address disinformation, EU institutions, national governments and civil society still struggle […]

Policy Study

29/11/2021

Despite increasing efforts to address disinformation, EU institutions, national governments and civil society still struggle to overcome one fundamental challenge. Disinformation actors can spread lies quickly and widely by adapting their messages to the news cycle and appealing to their readers’ emotions, concerns and value systems. In doing so, they set the tone and content of the conversation ahead of everyone else. This is demonstrated by recent events in Afghanistan and Belarus, where disinformation campaigns quickly sprang up online, aiming to feed public anxieties and reinforce the belief that Europe is facing a repeat of the 2015 ‘migration crisis’.

In this context, debunking efforts – fact-checking individual false claims after they have been published – usually fail to effectively counter the lies they are meant to counteract. Nor do they prevent disinformation actors from exploiting attention-grabbing events to manipulate public perception and steer social divisions. In contrast with debunking, this Issue Paper argues that disinformation should be pre-empted by taking strategic action before it begins to circulate. The guiding principle of this approach is that of ‘prebunking’.

Prebunking relies on two pillars, each linked to a specific timescale. In the short to medium term, efforts should be devoted to identifying false stories as early as possible, or even anticipating future narratives. In the longer term, citizens should be provided with the critical skills to distinguish facts from falsehoods and filter out manipulative content.

The EU prebunking system built through these actions will not only support ongoing efforts against disinformation. It will also help European citizens cope with and orient themselves within a rapidly changing information environment. It will promote an inclusive and fact-based public discourse. In a context where migration-related disinformation creates intergroup tensions and threatens the peace and security of European societies, prebunking efforts will also promote social cohesion, rebuild public trust and protect democratic institutions.

Read the Policy Study

This study is a result of a collaboration between the FEPS, the Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung and the European Policy Centre.

‘From debunking to prebunking’ is the latest outcome of a project that started in 2019. Fear and lying in the EU: Fighting disinformation on migration with alternative narratives is the previous publication.

Find all related publications
Publications
14/07/2022

Atypical work and the social protection of migrants in Europe

An analysis based on real cases
11/07/2022

Of wall and bridges

Guidelines for a policy of reception and inclusion of migrants
03/02/2022

Le Grand Enfumage

Does the populist vote rise where most immigrants settle? Do Europe’s far-right parties treat immigration […]
10/01/2022

Migrant key workers and social cohesion in Europe

Migration has become one of Europe’s most politically divisive issues. This Policy Study concentrates on […]
Find all related events
Events
Upcoming
28/09/2022
Brussels (Belgium)

Disinformation on migration after the invasion of Ukraine

Building up resilience against fake news
Past
11/01/2022

Migrant key workers and social cohesion in Europe

11 January 2022 As many other developed countries, the EU member states and the European […]
26/01/2022

Progressive Yearbook launch

Event, 26 January 2022 FEPS e-launched the third edition of one of its most unique […]