How to make the best use of the Resilience and Recovery Fund

The first results of the Recovery Watch research project were presented to the Italian public in Rome on 15 December

20/12/2022

“Assessing to improve” was the aim of the 15 December meeting held in Rome. Together with Forum Disuguaglianze e Diversità (FDD), FEPS presented the latest results of the Recovery Watch publication series. We made comparative analyses between the National Recovery and Resilience Plans (NRRPs) of different countries on four key social outcomes: the implementation of care policies with a gender perspective, the early childhood policies, the impact of climate measures on the labour market, and the attention paid in the implementation of the Plans to the specificities of locations and of the social dialogue.

David Rinaldi, Director of Studies and Public Policies at the FEPS, presented the four Recovery Watch studies revealing significant shortcomings in the NRRPs implementations. “This is not just a matter of how much money is spent in due time,” said Fabrizio Barca, Co-coordinator of the FDD, “but a matter of the social and economic effects of this spending.” 

There are now four steps that can be taken to fix the problems found:

  1. raise the quality of place-by-place monitoring;
  2. ensure that the infrastructures built under the NRRP are being used;
  3. strengthen the role of all the aggregations of municipalities (from metropolitan cities to project areas in inland areas) in connecting the various interventions together;
  4. effectively strengthen the administrations in charge through high-quality, competitive examinations.

Alessandra Faggian is Director of Social Sciences at the Gran Sasso Science Institute. She presented ‘How place-sensitive are the NRRPs?’, a research comparing the implementation of the Plans in Italy, Portugal and Spain. Analysing how these countries adopted the policies to the specificities of their locations through the dialogue with social partners, civil society and local administrations.

The countries have yet to establish the necessary conditions to ensure an informed, open and broad consultation on the definition of needs (both social and territorial) and on the challenges to address.

The recommendation for the European Commission is to ensure that there is actual participation in the implementation phase to compensate for the lack in the NRRPs’ construction one.

Laeticia Thissen, Policy Analyst for Gender Equality at FEPS, is the author of the study on eight National Recovery and Resilience Plans from a gender and care-led approach.

The national plans studied all address care, although to a significantly lower extent than other priorities and by mirroring pre-existing care regimes. Most Plans fail to take an intersectional and cross-border dimension of care. However, according to Thissen, a commitment to building stronger and more united social systems of care should be at the centre of the NRRP.

A total of 264,000 posts need to be created in childcare services and schools in Italy by the end of 2025 in order to receive three billion euros in funding. That money would be added to the 1.6 billion euros already in place for existing projects. Francesco Corti, Research Fellow at the Centre for European Policy Studies (CEPS), presented an analysis of the measures contained in the Recovery and Resilience Plans of five member states (Italy, Spain, Portugal, Germany and Slovakia). He focused on the effect of the NRRP on the creation of new nurseries. Italy, like Spain, uses the Recovery and Resilience Facility to increase the availability of services (measured in the number of new places created) and to reduce internal disparities between regions.

However, the target is not reached, even when considering private positions in addition to public ones. This is especially the case in the southern regions, with Campania and Sicily in the lead.

The last study concerned the strategies for a just climate transition by Maria Enrica Virgillito, Associate Professor in Political Economy at the Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna. She underlines that the climate transition must be a process that guarantees employment stability, environmental sustainability and economic equality in achieving the objective of climate neutrality.

Among the countries analysed in the study, those performing better are Sweden, Germany and Spain because they have already implemented industrial and mitigation/adaptation policies for the labour market in the years preceding the Plans.

The RRF is a program put in place in order to have a coordinated response to crises across Europe. It is only if this coordination is put in place effectively and if European citizens can understand its importance that we can then justify the surplus of additional public debt and make the exercise permanent. If not, it will prove to be counterproductive.

Watch the full event seminar (ITA)

Network
Forum Disuguaglianze e Diversità
Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung
Institut Emile Vandervelde
Find all related publications
Publications
25/01/2023

Progressive Yearbook 2023

Looking back to look ahead
11/01/2023

Promoting a just digital transition for workers

Recovery Watch series
10/01/2023

Systemic transformation or status quo?

Recovery Watch Series
15/12/2022

How place-sensitive are the NRRPs?

Recovery Watch series
Find all related events
Events
Upcoming
22/02/2023
Online (Expert meeting)

Social measures in the NRRPs

Recovery Watch series
Past
26/01/2023
FEPS HQ, Brussels

Progressive Yearbook launch 2023

Looking back to look ahead
30/11/2022
FEPS HQ, Brussels (Closed-door)

Territorial Just Transition Plans

Stakeholder meeting
Find all related news
News
20/12/2022

How to make the best use of the Resilience and Recovery Fund

The first results of the Recovery Watch research project were presented to the Italian public in Rome on 15 December
18/10/2022

Open letter to call for a deep reform of the EU fiscal rules

FEPS cosigned an open letter to EU leaders calling for them to address the underlying structural […]
30/05/2022

FEPS launches ‘Recovery Watch’, a new research project

The National Recovery and Resilience Plans represent the new framework in which member states will identify their […]
10/05/2022

Call to participants: Training Days for Social Business

Switzerland, September 3rd 2022
Find all related in the media
In the media

En Europe, le marché unique fête ses 30 ans, entre satisfaction et désillusion

by Le Monde 01/02/2023
'In Europe, the single market celebrates its 30th anniversary, between satisfaction and disillusionment' Le Monde article with an intervention by László Andor, FEPS Secretary General

L’Italia non riesce a usare il Pnrr: abbiamo speso solo un terzo dei 42 miliardi di euro stanziati

by L'Espresso 09/01/2023
'Italy fails to take advantage of the NRRP: we have spent only one-third of the 42 billion euros allocated' L'Espresso article on the implementation of the Recovery and Resilience Plans.

Gli effetti della crisi sulle famiglie e sul settore dell’agricoltura

by Radio Vaticana 19/12/2022
"The impact of the crisis on families and the agricultural sector" Radio Vaticana. Interview (18'45) with David Rinaldi, FEPS Director of Studies and Policy, on the Recovery Watch series of publications

Nuova economia ok, ma l’inquinamento?

by Il Fatto Quotidiano 19/12/2022
"A new economy OK, but what about pollution?" Il Fatto Quotidiano article on FEPS Policy Study "Policy challenges and actions for a just climate transition"